13 Comments
Mar 12Liked by Brooke Lea Foster

I used to be against marking up books, but sometimes I just have to. If I'm reading a rather long book or dense fantasy novel, I will mark passages with a highlighter and tab pages with small post-its. It helps me remember what's happened in the book.

Expand full comment

I underline, for sure. And I go back to novels and essayists and look for those passages. I love this essay on reading. You should see all my books by Nabokov--it was hard for me not underline everything--which of course would have been silly. but you get me point.

Expand full comment

Sorry to say, but I get really annoyed if I read a book that someone else has written in. My husband underlines when he reads, which “ruins” the book for me when I want to read it! I like to put removable tabs on pages when I read - I can go back to specific pages and re-read the passages I wanted to remember, without damaging the reading experience for someone else who might pick up that book in the future. I don’t mark the specific passage - just the page - so I can re-read the entire page and relive the reading experience.

Expand full comment

Yes! Yes, I do! And I just posed this question on my FB page last week. Especially curious to me was if others did this to fiction and not just nonfiction/self-help. With fiction, when a sentence makes me stop and gasp at its beauty, I want to capture it on the page. I used to dogear and sometimes I still do, but highlighting takes me right back to that beautiful passage. Do I ever go back? Umm. Nope. Not so far. Also, I don't write fiction. Yet. Not sure if I'll get around to that genre....

Expand full comment

I've only started doing this in the last year or two, but I'm a big fan of defacing books with my own scrawl and notes now. It makes them feel mine, it makes me feel more connected to them, plus it makes it good to come back to them and find sections I loved (or didn't love) and read my own note marginalia.

Expand full comment

I always want to be that person who marks up a book--nonfiction or fiction--but I just can't bring myself to do it. To me, stopping to highlight or underline impedes my enjoyment of the story. If I'm caught up in the book, I just want to read, read, read, not stop!

Expand full comment

Some prose are so perfect they need to be pondered and reflected upon. I certainly go back and smile at my highlights.

Expand full comment

Somehow, I find it hard to bring myself to mark up a book. I used to, in English class, for sure. But I have those urges and connections all the time when I'm reading! Sometimes I use post-its, but that gets hard to manage. After reading this, I feel like maybe I might change my thinking on this if it's a book I plan on keeping.

Expand full comment